DoodleKisses.com

Labradoodle & Goldendoodle Forum

Is eating dog any different than pork? Shocking Article that will make you think!

Whoa, I was taken aback when I read this article just now. I hope this doesn't offend anyone, and am sorry if it does, but I just couldn't help but see how others react to this.

 

The author sort of has a point. Why should puppy meat be any different then eating lamb? I have toyed with the idea of vegetarianism in the past but have never thought seriously about it. This article really left me feeling nautious about eating meat. Maybe I should give it a shot? I wonder how many DK members are vegetarian... 

 

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/the-hot-button/puppy-meat-no-di... 

 

Puppy meat no different than pork, celebrity chef argues

Globe and Mail Blog





| Getty Images/iStockphoto

You take a turn past the free-range chicken breast display and organic grass-fed beef ribs and approach the butcher's counter for the cut you're really interested in: succulent, organic canine brisket.

Just think: it would make a great pot roast for tonight and you'd have leftovers for the kids' lunches tomorrow.


Does the thought of puppy sandwiches trigger your gag reflex or bring a sympathetic tear to your eye? Well, British celebrity chef Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall says if you eat other types of meat, you should get a grip. He says he'd have no problems with a "high-welfare organic puppy farm," according to the Guardian.

"You can't object, unless you object to the farming of pigs," he says.

Mr. Fearnsley-Whittingstall wouldn't eat dog steak himself (he's recently become a vegetarian) but took the controversial stance to point out the hypocrisy among meat eaters who are happy to eat animals traditionally raised as livestock but are vehemently opposed to eating those raised as pets.

Our culture's opposition to eating puppies is based on a shaky foundation, he argues. At some point, we decided dogs would make great household companions and pigs (and cows and chickens) would be raised on farms and then grilled, fried and baked.

Surprise, surprise: not everyone's a fan of his stance.

A spokesman from the RSPCA told the Daily Mail, "...His comments may seem sensible but are actually quite controversial - especially when dogs are our most popular and loved pet."

Blogs reporting on the news have resorted to posting requisite photos of too-cute-for-words puppies to tug at our heartstrings.

But when dogs are cut up by a butcher (as is the case with pigs, cows and chickens) it's easier to get into a different head space about them, as this online puppy butcher proves. The butcher also doesn't identify what breed the meat comes from, all in an effort to make people separate "dogs as pets" from "dogs as dinner."

"We breed extra large, large, medium, small and extra small dogs in the one breed. This breed is not available as a pet which depersonalizes the Puppy Beef process. You wouldn't eat your pet lamb so we take a similar approach," they explain in their FAQ.

In Canada, dog meat is perfectly legal to serve at a restaurant - it just has to be properly inspected first.

If you eat other kinds of meat, would you ever chow down some baby back beagle ribs?

Views: 789

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I hear you Sharon, dogs are our friends. But what about the main point being made in the article, that other animals deserve the same respect... I can't help but feel guilty that while I love my dog and my cat my consumption of pork, chicken and beef contributes to a a food industry that treats animals horrendously. It wold be one thing if the meat we buy in the grocery store was from farm raised animals, but it's not. I have done a bit of readng and seen some documentaries about the food industry in North America and the treatment of animals is not pretty. That is the main point the guy in the article is making. If we can't tolerate that kind of treatment for our own animals then why do we condone it for other animals? I don't know, ... I like a good hamburger, but when I think about what that cow went through for me to have my dinner it makes my stomach churn...

i will answer this when i'm sober and wish to argue, this post has caused me my consternation...........night ladies.
oh no, please don't get stressed! Let's just agree to disagree!

No worries.  I just didnt want to keep yapping after sipping wine all evening. LOL

I certainly agree about the treatment of animals raised for consumption, its awful. When my daughter was very small (from the age 2 and up) she refused to eat meat.  I tried everything to get her to like it.  By the time she was a teenager, she insisted on being a  vegetarian.  I would only comply if she researched the proper foods for substitution. Took a lot of work to start cooking differently but we did it.  This was a great subject that has been difficult to digest....  

Sherri if you shop around you may be able to find meat from animals that have been treated humanely. I shop primarily at a local coop and not the chain stores. The coop does diligent research on the quality and treatment of the animals whose meat/eggs/dairy etc. they carry.  One of the beef ranches was actually certified  for humane treatment  (see link below).  We buy eggs and chicken from local farmers and the fowl are all on the ground and free ranging.  It's out there, at least in the U.S., if one wants to do the work and pay the extra cost.

http://www.charitywire.com/charity267/04114.html

I never even knew a place like this existed. Thank you for sharing. I am going to research and see if we have a beef ranch like this in our area. I would be willing to pay more.
Hope you are able to find something Laurie...let me know!
thank you Ricki! This is a great suggestion. I'll have to do some research in my area. I think it would be worth paying more, and perhaps eating meat a little less often if I could have some garauntees about the treatment of the animals and the quality of the meat.
It does help a little with the mental processes! I hope you are able to find some in your area!
At least people like Temple Grandin have worked to make the treatment of cattle more humane.

I love a burger, a steak, a chicken leg, a shell fish and a striped piece of meat with my eggs,....I also love seeing cows walking through the meadow, chickens in the hen house and pigs in the mud.

I think deer meat is disgusting, rabbit smells funny and fish does not appeal.

I don't begrudge anyone their tastes, however. KEEP THE HECK AWAY FROM MY DAISY...she is not food, she is my furbaby and I will filet YOU if you try anything funny Mr. Fearnsley-Whittingstal!

LOL! Not to worry, if you click to the article in the Guardian, he has gone vegetarian, which makes sense given the point he's trying to make with this outrageousness. :)

RSS

 

 Support Doodle Kisses 


 

DK - Amazon Search Widget

© 2025   Created by Adina P.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service