Labradoodle & Goldendoodle Forum
Tags:
Interesting.
The Tegan standard reads:
Height to length ratio should be as ten is to twelve, being slightly longer in leg than deep in body....
The Rutland Manor standard reads:
Slightly taller than long, on a ratio as twelve is to ten....
Those are profoundly different proportions.
Thanks those were interesting. I'm not sure that I would run out to hang my hat on the 1st study. It looked at OFA data and then measured pictures of BIS winners of different breeds and then found a correlation. It did not measure the dogs themselves and then look at their hips. It also did not follow the progeny of these dogs vs. dogs who tended to have proportions closer to 1. The second study looked at body mass, i.e. dogs who were heavy for their relative height.
I looked at a list of breeds who have a high and low percentage of HD and then I looked at their written standard to see if there was a correlation. I'm not sure I saw one.
Breeds with high percentage of HD and their ideal proportions according to the standard:
(Information for AKC web site and Cornell Vet College)
Bernese Mountain Dog (appearing square, slightly longer than tall)
Boxer (square)
Brittany Spaniel (square, any hint of being long is penalized)
Chesapeake Bay Retriever (Height slightly less than the body length)
English Springer Spaniel (length of the body is slightly greater than the height)
Golden Retriever (Length slightly greater than height ratio of 12:11)
German Shepherd Dogs (longer than tall, with the most desirable proportion as 10 to 8½)
Labrador Retriever (length is equal to or slightly longer than height)
Standard Poodle (square)
Rottweiler (height to length being 9 to 10)
Breeds with low incidence of HD
Borzoi (no proportion given.... dogs seem slightly longer than tall
Doberman Pinscher (square)
Great Dane (square)
Greyhound (no proportion given.... dogs do seem slightly longer than tall)
Irish Wolfhound (no clearly stated proportions but faults include too short in body)
Siberian Husky (slightly longer than the height)
I think that HD in a breed has more to do with the gene for it being passed down. You will notice that in breeds with low HD that 3 are coursing breeds and one is a serious draft breed. I think HD is not often seen in these breeds because historically if a dog could not run, it was put down and kept out of the breeding pool.
Anyway... back to the original issue. I don't think ALDs have finished being standardized and there is still a lot of variation out there in type. As far as becoming an AKC approved breed.... well the ALD has a long way to go and a number of hurdles that are going to be hard to clear.
© 2024 Created by Adina P. Powered by