DoodleKisses.com

Labradoodle & Goldendoodle Forum

Is eating dog any different than pork? Shocking Article that will make you think!

Whoa, I was taken aback when I read this article just now. I hope this doesn't offend anyone, and am sorry if it does, but I just couldn't help but see how others react to this.

 

The author sort of has a point. Why should puppy meat be any different then eating lamb? I have toyed with the idea of vegetarianism in the past but have never thought seriously about it. This article really left me feeling nautious about eating meat. Maybe I should give it a shot? I wonder how many DK members are vegetarian... 

 

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/the-hot-button/puppy-meat-no-di... 

 

Puppy meat no different than pork, celebrity chef argues

Globe and Mail Blog





| Getty Images/iStockphoto

You take a turn past the free-range chicken breast display and organic grass-fed beef ribs and approach the butcher's counter for the cut you're really interested in: succulent, organic canine brisket.

Just think: it would make a great pot roast for tonight and you'd have leftovers for the kids' lunches tomorrow.


Does the thought of puppy sandwiches trigger your gag reflex or bring a sympathetic tear to your eye? Well, British celebrity chef Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall says if you eat other types of meat, you should get a grip. He says he'd have no problems with a "high-welfare organic puppy farm," according to the Guardian.

"You can't object, unless you object to the farming of pigs," he says.

Mr. Fearnsley-Whittingstall wouldn't eat dog steak himself (he's recently become a vegetarian) but took the controversial stance to point out the hypocrisy among meat eaters who are happy to eat animals traditionally raised as livestock but are vehemently opposed to eating those raised as pets.

Our culture's opposition to eating puppies is based on a shaky foundation, he argues. At some point, we decided dogs would make great household companions and pigs (and cows and chickens) would be raised on farms and then grilled, fried and baked.

Surprise, surprise: not everyone's a fan of his stance.

A spokesman from the RSPCA told the Daily Mail, "...His comments may seem sensible but are actually quite controversial - especially when dogs are our most popular and loved pet."

Blogs reporting on the news have resorted to posting requisite photos of too-cute-for-words puppies to tug at our heartstrings.

But when dogs are cut up by a butcher (as is the case with pigs, cows and chickens) it's easier to get into a different head space about them, as this online puppy butcher proves. The butcher also doesn't identify what breed the meat comes from, all in an effort to make people separate "dogs as pets" from "dogs as dinner."

"We breed extra large, large, medium, small and extra small dogs in the one breed. This breed is not available as a pet which depersonalizes the Puppy Beef process. You wouldn't eat your pet lamb so we take a similar approach," they explain in their FAQ.

In Canada, dog meat is perfectly legal to serve at a restaurant - it just has to be properly inspected first.

If you eat other kinds of meat, would you ever chow down some baby back beagle ribs?

Views: 789

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I believe I ate Sea Cucumber in Japan. Wasn't so bad.
Ohhhh....I'm afraid to ask......   

The Sea Cucumber: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_cucumber 

 

Sea cucumbers are echinoderms from the class Holothuroidea. They are marine animals with a leathery skin and an elongated body containing a single, branched gonad. Sea cucumbers are found on the sea floor worldwide. There are a number of holothurian play /ˌhɒlɵˈθjʊəriən/ species and genera, many of which are targeted for human consumption. The harvested product is variously referred to as trepang, bêche-de-mer or balate.

Like all echinoderms, sea cucumbers have an endoskeleton just below the skin, calcified structures that are usually reduced to isolated microscopic ossicles (or sclerietes) joined by connective tissue. In some species these can sometimes be enlarged to flattened plates, forming an armour. In pelagic species such as Pelagothuria natatrix (Order Elasipodida, family Pelagothuriidae), the skeleton and a calcareous ring are absent

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I saw some in the ocean when I was in Guam. Had to struggle not to step on them. Basically, they look like big under water turds. YUMMY!!

GROSS!

 

OMD...I would have vomited right on top of him. What a total jerk in any language.
Can't read this!

My nieces are in College and university in the same area and have similiar friends. There was an asian exchange student that they became friends with and when she was leaving them she said that she would like to thank them with a meal. She asked where she could find dog to cook the meal with. Apparently my nieces and friends were stunned and slowly while trying not to throw up told her that we don't eat dog here. They were stunned.

I am shocked to see that it is legal to serve dog in Canada. What conditions are they raised in? We have enough trouble with puppy mills let alone this. Who is inspecting this meat? and where? I would suggest this is more of an underground ethnic practice?

We have raised our own animals for food. Chickens and pigs. The pigs are like pets, they are so smart and we had only a few at a time and they were raised outside and were more like the dogs than pigs. We could not over winter them as our barn was no longer in the condition to do so. Our kids played with them, they hung around us outside and took trips to the bush with us. the kids rode them. It was hard to take them to the butcher. But my husband said that they were the best looking happiest pigs there. It is done humanly and we did eat them and the kids we told after the first meal. They said that it was the best they ever had and were proud that they had given them a happy life.

My friend who leans towards vegetarianism also has a saying that she usually only eats meat when travelling as when she knows the animal has lead a happy life and not been factory farmed she feels it has been done with the outmost respect for the animal.

I guess each  culture has its own food chain? 

I understand that the bare bones logic makes sense...an animal is an animal...if you're gonna eat one why be picky?  BUT, I'm with Cindy on this one.  After all human meat would be the most nutritionally complete meat for humans, right?  All the right amino acids already there!  But...um...beyond sickening and definitely not moral in my book.

 

I'm mostly vegetarian but do eat fish now and then and occasionally I'll eat poultry when I eat out or on Thanksgiving. 

For starters here I am gonna say that the article turns my stomach.

Secondly I am gonna tell you to read the "perfectly legal" link in that article until you get to the last sentence where it states there is no facility to inspect dog meat in Canada.

I do eat meat....I do not eat lamb,rabbit,deer,moose.....but I do have fish,chicken,pork and beef.

That being said I am going to play the devils advocate:

We are VERY lucky that we have the money to pick and choose what we eat and the way we eat.Some people are not that lucky and do a lot of eating from what they have hunted or fished.My Father grew up very poor....his father was only in his 30's when rocks fell on him in the coal mines and crushed his spine.....he was paralyzed from the waist down for the rest of his life....grandma took care of him until he died in his 60's.They had 9 kids.So did they eat rabbit,fish,deer,moose...absolutely....anything they could take home and cook for a meal for the family.

My father went into the airforce at 16 to be able to send money home...became a pilot.He then went back to university first to become an RN and then to obtain his BSC and BED....he is a brilliant man.He still likes to eat kinds of meat that I personally dont eat.My point is that it is what you grew up with....it is what is normal in your country or culture.It has nothing to do with education but lots to do with economy.

 

Would I ever advocate for pets to be eaten>>>NEVER....but in some cultures it is the norm as sad as it is to us as lovers of our furry family members.

I can guarantee though that if you were stranded and starving to death you would do whatever you had to do for survival.

Anyway...I just wanted to put that out there....please dont lynch me...lol

 

I won't lynch you. I agree. It's a sad story about your grandfather and an inspiring one about your dad.
Ditto to that.  My dad was raised on a farm.  Farm animals are just that, farm animals.  Dogs on the other hand are for human companionship, security alarms, etc.  I grew up eating rabbit, squirrel, deer  etc..  I've tried ground hog (gag) mostly fatty tasting, elk, good; deer; good; rabbit; very good; squirrel, if I must; doves (yes there is actually still a season on Penna books to shoot and kill them) well I dunno, takes a lot of doves to make a meal LOL; possum, omg NO;  bear, um,, well ok, But as of late, I might develop more of a taste for them! I had a grandma from the Appalachians that caught snapping turtle - WOW, that was delicious!!  Frog legs, well I've gotta tell ya, ITS BETTER THAN CHICKEN.   I'm not adverse to trying out different animals that have been forever thought of as food. But by gawd you start talking about puppies and I could cry.  If I"m dying and starving, I'm gonna find whatever I can to eat and share with my dog!
Additionally, I know I've said more than enough here already..I prefer to shop at the market....however.  If need be, I'm prepared to eat the animals that our ancestors have been eating, and it does NOT include dog.  

RSS

 

 Support Doodle Kisses 


 

DK - Amazon Search Widget

© 2024   Created by Adina P.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service